2010 NFL Combine: QBs, WRs and RBs…and Tim Tebow

When Tim Tebow decided to participate in the 2010 Senior Bowl, college football fans from all over flocked to Ladd-Peebles Stadium. But following the game, critics and draft analysts proceeded to pick apart his throwing motion from his awkward release to his unorthodox throwing base. And it may have been the best thing for him. He immediately began to rebuild his motion, which appeared to be the only flaw in his brand. When he decided not to throw in this year’s NFL Combine, the criticism started all over. But there’s no denying his leadership, his faith, his likeability, his will to win — perfect combination for the face of any franchise.

Joining Tebow in the “I’ll throw during my Pro Day” club were Sam Bradford, Jimmy Clausen and Colt McCoy all of whom are working through some sort of injury. Dan LeFevour of Central Michigan added his name to that list as he also continues to improve his throwing form. And the criticism continues. But will it even matter come draft day? All of the above are among the best at the quarterback position, and have walked the walk throughout their respective careers.

Not The Size, But The Motion. This seems to be the appropriate theme for this year’s crop of QBs. Of the top prospects, only Tony Pike & Sam Bradford have the height that scouts regard as “ideal”, but the knock for both has been their weight…or lack thereof. Dan LeFevour is the closest thing to the perfect package at 6′3-1/4″, 230. Unfortunately, he doesn’t share the same spotlight as the aforementioned group.

Read the rest of this entry »

Popularity: 3% [?]

New Heisman Candidates Emerge For 2009

Tim Tebow & Sam Bradford went down early…and hard. [Reinke|AP Photo, Jenkins|AP]—–

This college football season has been enigmatic at best. But the uncertainty has also realigned the Heisman race…not to mention two of the three top Heisman candidates suffered serious injuries early on, and Colt McCoy started off slower than anyone expected.

A new group of candidates has emerged. Ok…let’s not use “emerged”. Based on their performances last season, Colt McCoy, Tim Tebow and Sam Bradford were placed on the pedestal before the first snap was taken. But now those that were destined to be noticed are getting the attention they deserve. Despite the discernable nepostism in the beginning, we can focus on some new candidates for now.

My Top 5 Heisman candidates through Week 5:

[5] Jahvid Best. There’s no denying his talent. His acceleration is second-to-none. His video game moves are responsible for many broken ankles. (Random stat warning) He’s second among active players in number of career rushing attempts of 70 or more yards [thanks, HP]. But Best’s Heisman run is quickly coming to a halt. Oregon held him to 55 yards and USC to 47 yards…both resulting in only 3.4 yards per carry. Assuming he and his team can get back on track, he’s still worth a top nod. One more poor performance would definitely knock him off his perch. Next opponent: UCLA (3-1)

[4] Colt McCoy. Colt may have had a sluggish start, but the gunslinger is beginning to show his true colors once again. Coming off a bye week, McCoy doesn’t boast the huge Heisman stats in yards and TDs. Despite 5 picks to date, he has completed 71.0 pct of his passes, which is second in the nation. And he’s still sitting on a respectable passer rating of 151.0. Next opponent: Colorado (1-3)

[3] Tony Gerhart. Tony who? Tony “Leads The Nation In Rushing” Gerhart. With 650 yards rushing and 8 TDs, he’s the current pacesetter for rushing yards and only two scores away from the touchdown title. It’s also worth pointing out that the Stanford running back shares a conference with three other names you’ve probably heard: Jahvid Best, Joe McKnight and Jacquizz Rodgers. And don’t forget the exiled LaGarrette Blount. It’s probably safe to say that Stanford is 4-1 as a result of Gerhart’s efforts not to mention they’re #1 in the Pac-10. Next opponent: Oregon State (3-2)

[2] Tony Pike. While it may be surprising to most college football fans that Cincinnati is undefeated and ranked #8 in the nation, it’s more surprising that they’re the highest ranked team in the state of Ohio. While the debate for the best team rages on, there’s no debtate as to which Ohio QB is better. Pike has racked up nearly 1,500 yards through the air resulting in 13 TDs. No. 23 South Florida will arguably be Pike’s stiffest competition. This natoinally-televised matchup will be his best opportunity to impress voters. Next opponent: University of South Florida (5-0)

[1] Jimmy Clausen. Jimmy’s got a gun, and he’s definitely on a run. Despite the fact that the Irish can thank their lucky charms that they’re 4-1 (last three wins by 3, 2 and 7), Jimmy continues to shine brightly beneath the watchful eye of Touchdown Jesus. He boasts the highest passer rating (179.3) and is fourth in passing yards (1,544) with nearly 40% of those coming from playmaker, Golden Tate. But most impressive might be the scarcity of turnovers. He’s thrown 2 INTs to his 12 TDs thus far. Next opponent in 2 weeks: USC (4-1)

Don’t Forget These Guys. When your three sexiest Heisman hopefuls don’t pan out, the Heisman race becomes such a crap shoot. The five guys on the list above might be the most photogenic, but there are a handful that are making their case week after week. Up until last night, Missouri QB Blaine Gabbert had impressed fans and experts with his athleticism. University of Miami QB Jacory Harris reminds me of Pat White — a great talent that just doesn’t seem to attract enough Heisman attention to make a case. If you ask him, he’s definitely made one.

Jake Locker is more than just the signal caller for the University of Washington. He’s their leader…their savior. As he goes, they go. He plays well under pressure and is unphased in big game situations. While he may not garner Heisman consideration, he’ll undoubtedly be one of the most sought after QBs in the upcoming NFL draft.

While Jevan Snead was destined to do big things at Ole Miss, teammate Dexter McCluster has shown why he’s just as important to that offense. Neither will separate themselves as the superstar, but their team better for it. Alabama should give them every opportunity to highlight their respective talents.

University of Houston QB Case Keenum may make the best case to be in that list above. He’s already passed for nearly 1,700 yards and 13 TDs…the only blemishes on his stat sheet are 2 INTs. The Cougs suffered an unfortuntate loss to UTEP last week after two impressive wins against Oklahoma State and Texas Tech. The remainder of their schedule gives Houston an opportunity to bounce back and therefore Case another moment in the spotlight.

Alabama QB Greg McElroy—–

Under The Radar…For Now. Alabama QB Greg McElroy has flown way under the radar. It’s probably because his numbers aren’t eye popping. But his passer rating of 165.5 ranks fifth nationally. Tim Tebow isn’t the only leader to use an eye bulging, red-faced “talkin’ to” to get his team fired up. McElroy used some choice words in their win over Kentucky before leading them down the field on a 97-yard scoring drive.

Popularity: 28% [?]

2009 NCAA Football — Don’t Overlook These Quarterbacks

At a recent Pigskin Preview luncheon in San Antonio, ESPN College Football Analyst Todd Blackledge warmed up the audience with an analogy passed on to him by one of his former Penn State teammates. He said “quarterbacks are like tea bags…put him in hot water to see how strong he really is”.

Don’t forget about Zac Robinson. He won’t let you.—–

Quarterback is perhaps the most prominent position in today’s football game. Focus on the spread offense has resulted in a reduced number of carries for running backs placing the outcome of games squarely in the hands of the field general. Perhaps that is why more and more often, the frontrunner Heisman candidates are QBs.

This year we see three familiar faces leading the Heisman race: Colt McCoy, Tim Tebow and Sam Bradford. They’re certainly deserving of the attention. Unfortunately a handful of great players will be overshadowed by their amplitude.

Zack Robinson, Oklahoma State. The 6-3, 218-pound QB showed made his statement as a dual threat. He complied 3,064 passing yards and 562 yards on the ground. With the exception of the game against Texas Tech in 2008, Robinson scored through the air or on the ground at least once per game. And speaking of hot water, the Cowboys will open its season against one of its formidable opponents of the season at home against Georgia.

Williams will keep opponents on their heels.—–

Juice Williams, Illinois. In 2008, Juice amassed 3,173 yards through the air and 719 more on the ground. That’s more passing yards and rushing yards than Tim Tebow and Colt McCoy respectively. He also threw for 22 TDs, which could conceivably get a boost with WR Arrelious Benn at his side (see 7-to-9.com). Hopefully the team can put the 5-7 2008 season behind them.

Jevan Snead, Ole Miss. Is it ridiculous to assume Jevan will compete with Colt McCoy once again? This time it’s for the Heisman. The native Texan, and former Longhorn, got better with age throughout the 2008 season. After his Rebels knocked off the Florida Gators, they had two disappointing loses. Ole Miss proceeded to win its last five games as well as a Cotton Bowl victory against Texas Tech. In those final six games, Snead threw for 16 TDs and only 3 picks. Now that he’s finally settled in Oxford, perhaps he can carry that momentum into this season.

The Rest. After the three QBs listed above, there are several others worth watching. Terrelle Pryor of Ohio State didn’t have extraordinary stats in 2008. But he did lead the Big Ten in passing efficiency. Penn State QB Daryll Clark will be another Big Ten standout. He kept picks in the single digits and passed for over 2,500 yards. Arkansas QB Ryan Mallett has the potential to flourish under Bobby Petrino’s offense. Robert Griffin at Baylor boasts a wealth of athleticism. A tough conference schedule will likely keep him out of top player consideration, but he’ll be exciting to watch. There are others that have definitely garnered some attention, but these preseason favorites shouldn’t disappoint.

Popularity: 23% [?]

5 Unsexy Heisman Candidates for 2008

It’s hard to criticize the purpose and prestige of the Heisman Trophy without sounding disrespectful of John W. Heisman and the Downtown Athletic Club (DAC). I think the word I’m looking for is “disappointed”. With the obvious nepotism influence from all the media exposure today, the top candidates are assigned some degree of “the right stuff at the right time”. It just seems that all of the variables that go into picking the best college football player have been abandoned…it’s now the “which quarterback is kicking ass on the team with the best record” award. Boooring. As a fan of Big 12 teams, this shouldn’t pose a problem for me. But it does.

So where’s the objectivity? Who’s to say the candidate’s team record is even a variable? The DAC doesn’t…not really. Ok. A winning record helps…and should help as it is often a reflection of the candidates’ accomplishments. But use NFL Barry Sanders as an example. He’s arguably one the best running backs ever…top 3 or 5. But the Lions were horrible and yet no one ignored the fact that Barry was a great player on a mediocre team.

I digress…a little.

RECORD, SCHMECORD. If you go back to previous Heisman winner team records, there are a handful of players that won the prestigious award with more than 2 losses.

• Ricky Williams — Texas, 9-3 (1998)
• Ty Detmer — BYU, 10-3 (1990)
• Tim Brown — Notre Dame, 8-4 (1987)
• Bo Jackson — Auburn, 8-4 (1985)
• Marcus Allen — USC, 9-3 (1981)
• Paul Hornung — Notre Dame, 2-8 (1956)

PRO “ACCOMPLISHMENTS”. Don’t even get me started on this one. I’m not the only one who’s ever spouted the words “Heisman curse”. Only 8 Heisman winners are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. However, to the credit of previous Heisman campaigns there have been a bunch of finalists that have flourished at the next level. Just check out the finalists the year Herschel Walker won the Heisman (1982). I will admit that I’m placing too much focus on pro potential when the award is for the best college player. But it helps (a little) get the point across.

WHERE ARE THEY NOW? Jason White. Eric Crouch. Chris Weinke. Danny Wuerffel. Forget the ones that are still in “the league” struggling or have been subjected to bench warming duties. Ok, ok…back to the pro potential argument, but you get the point.

WHO ELSE IS THERE? The Heisman Class of 2005 may be the exception. The two best college players were arguably Reggie Bush and Vince Young. They were certainly two of the most exciting to watch.

Ok, Mr. Know-It-All. Who do you like for Heisman consideration this year?

[1] MICHAEL CRABTREE, WR — Texas Tech. Hate the Red [over]Raiders all you want. Michael Crabtree is already a top consideration…just the most underappreciated one. He’s got T.O.’s strength (head-to-head with physical corners, breaking tackles), Andre Johnson’s “go get it”, and a dabble of Lynn Swann’s grace. Forget that Texas Tech passes a bunch more than most teams; his numbers don’t overshadow his talent. Just watch him and you’ll agree. I’ll try not to hold this against him.

84 receptions, 1,072 yards, 18 TDs

[2] BRIAN JOHNSON, QB — Utah. If there’s a solid, pro-ready QB in college football, it’s Brian Johnson. He willed the Utes to win in big game situations. No matter what you think of TCU and BYU, they still provided big pressure situations for Johnson. And he came through. I realize it’s tough to compare his accomplishments to the three Big 12 QBs…and Tim Tebow. No doubt those guys have impressed with their big numbers and “will his team to win” performances. Brian Johnson has done the same with what he’s got. And I’d put my chips on the ability of Johnson at the next level.

2,636 yards, 24 TDs, 68.3% completion pct

[3] NATE DAVIS, QB — Ball State. If there’s another solid, pro-ready QB in college football, it’s Nate Davis. He has great awareness and field vision…a point guard on the football field. He’s got a powerful arm, but a weapon whose intensity he controls very well. He’s impressive with the long ball (even on the run), but more importantly he places the ball with precision in the short game. He’s like a Swiss Army knife. And as a bonus, the first NFL team to call Nate Davis up to their roster also get mobility. Not normally something I really care about, but I like the fact that he is a pass-first, pass-second QB. Surely some video geek doing nothing in his dorm can hook Nate up with a proper highlight video. His performance against Indiana is as good as it gets for now.

3,095 yards, 25 TDs, 67.3% completion pct

[4] PAT WHITE, QB — West Virginia. Pat White is the closest thing to the Heisman norm as dictated by recent winners. Pat White is a QB with a great set of abilities including great arm strength and accuracy. But he’s not afraid to tuck it up and run. In last week’s win over Louisville, White rushed for 200 yards breaking the QB rushing record of former Missouri QB Brad Smith (4,292). He’s obviously a product of the system Rich Rodriguez left behind. Don’t get me wrong…he has the tools to play QB at the next level. Unfortunately his predecessors have either experienced short-lived lives as QBs or have proven that a move to WR have been beneficial.

1,226 passing yards, 17 passing TDs, 65.4% completion pct, 786 rishing yards, 7 rushing TDs

[5] LESEAN “SHADY” McCOY, RB — Pitt. This guy is the real McCoy (that was too easy). Seriously, though, if you’ve never seen Lesean run the ball, you’re missing out. The best way to describe his running style is…um…imagine the light bike scene in Tron (about 1:08). That should do it. Lesean McCoy broke Tony Dorsett’s freshman rushing TD record (14) and rushed for over 110 yards per game. Going into tonight’s Backyard Brawl against West Virginia, he’s already chalked up 16 scores. He’s only a sophomore. So, if he doesn’t catch your attention this season, he will in the future.

1,125 yards, 18 TDs, 5.0 yards/carry

I know none of these guys will win. The current Heisman Trophy candidates are all great athletes and have been effective leaders for each of their respective teams. Without taking anything away from their accomplishments, I just believe that the purpose of the Heisman Trophy has been lost over the years as TV coverage favors the sexier teams in the bigger conferences. For those of us disenchanted college football fans, I really don’t care who wins the award anymore.

Popularity: 17% [?]